A DUI arrest in Naples starts two cases at once: a criminal charge in Collier County Court and an administrative license suspension that must be challenged within 10 days. Florida’s DUI penalties rise with each prior conviction and with a breath or blood level of 0.15 or higher. The Naples attorneys below handle first-time, repeat, and felony DUI cases. This guide to the Best DUI Defense Lawyers in Naples, FL helps readers explore local legal representation.
1. The Caldarone Law Group, P.A.
- Attorney: Justin P. Caldarone, Esq.
- Address: 2500 Airport Road South, Suite 307, Naples, FL 34112
- Phone: (239) 420-7205
- Website: caldaronelawgroup.com
- Practice Focus: Amputation, Arson, Battery, Bicycle Accident, Birth Injury, Boat Injury, Bribery, Burn Injury, Car Accident, Catastrophic Injury, Child Abuse, Commercial Vehicle Accident, Criminal Defense, Distracted Driving Accident, Dog Bite, Domestic Violence Defense, Driving Without License, Drug Crime, Drug Possession, Drug Trafficking, Drunk Driving Accident, DUI, Elderly Driver Car Accident, Escape Charges, Expungement, Fleeing and Eluding, Gun Crime, Head Injury, Homicide, Insurance Claims, Juvenile Crime, Kidnapping, Leaving the Scene of an Accident, Medical Malpractice, Medication Error, Motorcycle Accident, Negligent Security, Pedestrian Accident, Perjury, Personal Injury, Post-Conviction, Premises Liability, Probation Violation, Product Liability, Prostitution, Resisting Arrest, Rideshare Accident, Robbery, Sex Crime, Spinal Cord Injury, Swimming Pool Injury, Theft, Traumatic Brain Injury, Trespassing, Truck Accident, Violent Crime, White Collar Crime, Workers’ Compensation, Wrongful Death, Uber Accident
- Experience: Former Assistant State Attorney, Miami-Dade County; J.D., Northeastern (2002); admitted in all Florida state and federal courts
- Results: Firm reports a not guilty DUI verdict
- Languages: Spanish and Haitian Creole spoken
- Google Rating: 5.0 ★ (70 reviews)
- Google Business Profile: View on Google Maps
- Social Profiles: Facebook | LinkedIn | X | Instagram
About: The Caldarone Law Group, P.A. defends drivers through its Naples DUI practice, which also covers driving without a license, fleeing and eluding, and leaving the scene. Justin P. Caldarone earned his J.D. from Northeastern University School of Law in 2002 and tried hundreds of misdemeanor and felony cases as a Miami-Dade Assistant State Attorney, so he knows how DUI cases are built from the stop forward.
He reviews the legality of the traffic stop, how field exercises were run, and how breath or blood was tested. The firm reports a not guilty DUI verdict, and a client review credits him with clearing a habitual traffic offender designation that had kept a license suspended for years. Spanish and Haitian Creole are spoken. The Caldarone Law Group, P.A. is featured in this guide to the Best DUI Defense Lawyers in Naples, FL.
2. Cavanaugh & Cavanaugh, P.A.
- Attorneys: Daniel M. Cavanaugh, Shayna K. Cavanaugh
- Address: 2180 Immokalee Rd, Suite 309, Naples, FL 34110
- Phone: (239) 309-2006
- Website: cavanaughattorneys.com
- Practice Focus: First, second, third, felony, underage, and drug DUI; BUI
- Experience: ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist (2022); former prosecutor who supervised DUI prosecutors; AV Preeminent
About: Daniel M. Cavanaugh moved to Naples in 1997 and has tried cases for more than 25 years. As a prosecutor he supervised other prosecutors handling DUI cases in Florida and Vermont, and he later earned the ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientist designation (2022), training that targets blood and breath testing errors. The firm’s DUI Law Group handles first, second, third, felony, underage, and drug DUI plus BUI, and reports dismissals in drug DUI, 0.15+ BAC, and crash cases. He holds an AV Preeminent rating, and the team speaks Spanish.
3. Verderamo Law
- Attorneys: J. Derek Verderamo, Adam Carney
- Address: 2662 Airport-Pulling Rd S, Naples, FL 34112
- Phone: (239) 775-1004
- Website: verderamolaw.com
- Practice Focus: DUI, DUI formal review hearings, suspended license, reckless driving, BUI
- Experience: Trial firm with Naples and Fort Myers offices
About: Verderamo Law is led by J. Derek Verderamo and Adam Carney, with offices in Naples and Fort Myers serving clients from Marco Island to Lehigh Acres. The firm keeps separate pages for DUI, DUI formal review hearings, suspended licenses, reckless driving, and boating under the influence, so it handles both the criminal case and the license fight. Derek Verderamo previously practiced at Verderamo & Nunez and Verderamo & Escobar and belongs to the Collier County and Florida criminal defense lawyers associations. The firm offers free confidential consultations and a Spanish-language page.
4. Day, Gorman & Hopkins, PLLC
- Attorneys: Donald P. Day Jr., Thomas R. Gorman III, Michael E. Hopkins
- Address: 3550 Tamiami Trail E, Naples, FL 34112
- Phone: (239) 529-6053
- Practice Focus: DUI, criminal defense
- Experience: All attorneys are former Twentieth Circuit prosecutors; Michael Hopkins recognized by Naples Illustrated Top Lawyers
About: Donald P. Day Jr., Thomas R. Gorman III, and Michael E. Hopkins all prosecuted cases for the Twentieth Judicial Circuit before turning to defense, and their office sits within walking distance of the Collier County Courthouse. Avvo reviewers single out Mike Hopkins for DUI work, and he has been recognized repeatedly by Naples Illustrated Top Lawyers. Thomas Gorman holds an AV Preeminent rating, and Donald Day has been recognized among The National Trial Lawyers Top 100.
5. Law Offices of Jose Nunez, Jr.
- Attorney: Jose Nunez, Jr.
- Address: 3606 Enterprise Ave, Suite 226, Naples, FL 34104
- Phone: (239) 260-4699
- Practice Focus: DUI, criminal defense, domestic violence
- Experience: As an Assistant State Attorney in Naples and Fort Myers, his trial work emphasized DUI and battery cases
About: Jose Nunez, Jr. grew up in Naples and served as an Assistant State Attorney in Naples and Fort Myers, where his trial work emphasized DUI and battery and he averaged about one jury trial a month. That gives him a prosecutor’s view of breath testing, officer testimony, and plea offers in Collier County DUI cases. He spent four years as a partner at Verderamo & Nunez before opening his own firm and belongs to FACDL, NACDL, and the Collier County Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.
6. Musca Law
- Attorney: John Patrick Musca and team
- Address: 3375 Tamiami Trail E, Suite 200, Naples, FL 34112
- Phone: (239) 793-5297
- Practice Focus: DUI, license suspension hearings, criminal defense
- Experience: Statewide firm; describes 150+ combined years; calls answered 24/7
About: Musca Law, led by John Patrick Musca, is a statewide defense firm describing more than 150 combined years of experience, with two Naples offices on Tamiami Trail East and Davis Boulevard. Its phones are answered by a person around the clock, including Sundays. Google reviewers describe licenses restored before court, a suspension invalidated with no record left behind, and help on a second DUI after a prior lawyer’s loss.
7. Timothy E. Moffitt, Esq., LLC
- Attorney: Timothy E. Moffitt
- Address: 501 Goodlette-Frank Rd, Naples, FL 34102
- Phone: (239) 298-6538
- Practice Focus: DUI, driving while license suspended, traffic, criminal defense
About: Timothy E. Moffitt (Florida Bar No. 613711) describes his DUI practice as aggressive and results-oriented and also handles driving while license suspended and criminal traffic charges. He takes felonies and misdemeanors and handles appeals. Google reviewers describe quick, clear communication and tickets resolved without points or long drives to court.
8. Law Offices of Mark A. Casassa
- Attorney: Mark A. Casassa
- Address: 2671 Airport-Pulling Rd S, Suite 301, Naples, FL 34112
- Phone: (239) 417-0999
- Practice Focus: DUI, criminal defense
- Experience: Licensed for more than 40 years
About: Mark A. Casassa has been licensed for more than 40 years and lists DUI as a primary practice area on Avvo. Clients describe trial wins, a dismissal after a wrongful arrest, and a DUI client who said he always returns calls. One reviewer has referred clients to him for 15 to 20 years in Naples and Fort Myers.
9. Nico J. Vitale, P.A.
- Attorney: Nico J. Vitale
- Address: 2681 Airport-Pulling Rd S, Suite C107, Naples, FL 34112
- Phone: (239) 774-9900
- Practice Focus: DUI, traffic, criminal defense
- Experience: Member of CCACDL and FACDL
About: Nico J. Vitale runs Nico J. Vitale, P.A. on Airport-Pulling Road and belongs to the Collier County and Florida criminal defense lawyers associations. His listed practice includes DUI, traffic tickets, and a full range of criminal charges. Reviewers describe him as attentive, efficient, and confident in court.
10. Law Firm of Scott T. Moorey
- Attorney: Scott T. Moorey
- Address: 2663 Airport Rd S, Suite D108, Naples, FL 34112
- Phone: (239) 388-2959
- Practice Focus: DUI, criminal defense, expungement
- Experience: About 27 years of criminal defense experience
About: Scott T. Moorey has about 27 years of Florida criminal defense experience and practices on Airport Road near the courthouse complex. He lists DUI alongside criminal defense and expungement, so clients can address record relief after a case closes. Google reviewers describe a responsive, straightforward team. Readers comparing the Best DUI Defense Lawyers in Naples, FL can consider his documented practice areas and experience.
Collier County DUI Courts and Process
- Misdemeanor DUI: Collier County Court, Collier County Courthouse, 3315 Tamiami Trail East, Naples.
- Felony DUI: Collier County Circuit Court, same courthouse.
- License: Request a DHSMV review hearing within 10 days of arrest.
- Records: Collier County Clerk of Courts
About This List
The Caldarone Law Group, P.A. sponsors this article and appears first. The other nine firms have Naples offices, public Google Business Profiles, and verified DUI or criminal traffic practices. Ratings were recorded on October 19, 2026. This list is not a ranking. Verify credentials through The Florida Bar. The Best DUI Defense Lawyers in Naples, FL guide is an editorial resource for researching local attorneys.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the penalties for a first DUI in Florida?
Under Statute 316.193, a first conviction carries a fine of $500 to $1,000 and up to 6 months in jail, plus probation, at least 50 hours of community service, and a 10-day vehicle impoundment.
What changes if my BAC was 0.15 or higher?
A first conviction at 0.15 or higher, or with a minor in the car, raises the fine to $1,000 to $2,000, the maximum jail to 9 months, and requires an ignition interlock for at least 6 months.
What about a second DUI?
A second conviction carries a fine of $1,000 to $2,000, up to 9 months in jail, and an interlock for at least 1 year. A second offense within 5 years of the first requires at least 10 days in jail.
When is a DUI a felony?
A third conviction within 10 years, any fourth conviction, and DUI causing serious bodily injury are third-degree felonies. DUI manslaughter is a second-degree felony with a 4-year mandatory minimum.
How long do I have to save my license?
You generally have 10 days from the arrest to request a review of the administrative suspension with the DHSMV.
