Looking for car accident lawyers in Toledo? This guide covers 10 law firms that handle collision claims for injured drivers and passengers in Toledo and the surrounding Lucas County area: Johnson & Associates, Williams DeClark Tuschman, Cubbon & Associates, Zoll & Kranz, Turley & McCarthy, Charles E. Boyk Law Offices, Kisling, Nestico & Redick, Zychowicz Law, Elk & Elk, and Arthur Law Firm. Each firm was evaluated on its attorneys’ professional backgrounds and credentials, auto accident and jury trial experience, practice focus, peer recognition such as Best Law Firms, Best Lawyers and Super Lawyers and the availability of a Toledo-area office. You can also explore our listicle on personal injury lawyers in Toledo for a broader look at local attorneys and their practice areas.
When comparing car accident lawyers in Toledo, three practical questions matter most. Does the attorney regularly litigate in the Lucas County Court of Common Pleas, where most Toledo injury lawsuits are filed? Does the firm have the resources to prove fault in a disputed crash, such as accident reconstruction experts and a record of jury trials? And can the firm handle the insurance side of the claim, including underinsured motorist coverage and bad faith disputes, alongside the lawsuit itself?
This list is not ranked and not sponsored. Contact details, credentials and practice areas come from each firm’s own website, supplemented by Best Law Firms and Best Lawyers listings and attorney directories such as Avvo and FindLaw where a specific recognition is cited.
1. Johnson & Associates
- Attorney/Key Figure: D. Lee Johnson, Attorney
- Headquarters: 2927 N. McCord Road, Suite 100, Toledo, OH 43615
- Phone: (419) 843-2424
- Website: leejohnsonlegal.com
- Practice Areas: Car accidents (including distracted driving, drunk driving and rideshare accidents), truck, motorcycle, pedestrian, bicycle, boat, train and golf cart accidents, catastrophic injury, workplace injury, insurance bad faith claims, workers’ compensation, medical malpractice, nursing home negligence, negligent security, wrongful death
- Firm Size: Boutique firm founded in 1998 with over 40 years of combined experience across its team
- Practice Area Page: Toledo Car Accident Lawyer
- Social Profiles: Facebook, X, LinkedIn, YouTube
Johnson & Associates was founded on January 4, 1998, by attorney D. Lee Johnson, a University of Toledo College of Law graduate who has been admitted to practice in Ohio and in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio since 1990. He is a diplomate in civil trial advocacy with the Association of Trial Lawyers of America and belongs to the Ohio Academy of Trial Lawyers, the Lucas County Trial Lawyers Association and the Toledo Bar Association. The firm also reports his membership on the Ohio Board of Professional Conduct.
What sets the firm apart on collision cases is its bench of retained experts. Johnson & Associates works with 3D accident reconstruction specialists and former Toledo Police Department and Ohio State Highway Patrol officers who can explain crash dynamics and help establish which driver was at fault. Its published results include a $1.1 million auto accident settlement, a $933,333 court settlement in an auto accident case and a $5.575 million wrongful death verdict, and its car accident practice has dedicated pages for distracted driving, drunk driving and rideshare crashes. The firm also pursues uninsured motorist claims against a client’s own insurer when the at-fault driver has no coverage.
2. Cubbon & Associates
- Attorney/Key Figure: Stuart F. Cubbon, Managing Partner
- Headquarters: One SeaGate, Suite 1845, Toledo, OH 43604
- Phone: (419) 243-7243
- Website: cubbon.com
- Practice Areas: Auto accidents, trucking accidents, motorcycle accidents, wrongful death, bicycle and electric scooter accidents, insurance bad faith claims
- Firm Size: Boutique firm of three attorneys (Stuart F. Cubbon, James E. Yavorcik, Phillip S. Cubbon), representing injury victims since 1953
- Practice Area Page: Auto Accidents
Cubbon & Associates was founded in 1953 by Frank W. Cubbon Jr. Stuart F. Cubbon joined in 1981, is board certified in civil trial advocacy by the National Board of Trial Advocacy, has been named an Ohio Super Lawyer since 2008, and is a past president of the Toledo Bar Association. His practice is devoted entirely to litigation, split roughly between vehicular collisions (50%), other personal injury (25%) and wrongful death (25%). Attorney James E. Yavorcik has practiced for more than 40 years, is also a board certified civil trial advocate, and previously served as an assistant Lucas County prosecutor.
Few Toledo firms put as much of their caseload into collisions. Best Law Firms ranks Cubbon Tier 1 in Toledo for Personal Injury Litigation, Plaintiffs, and local attorneys quoted on Avvo describe referring complex injury matters to the firm. The trade-off is size: with three attorneys, its bench is smaller than the statewide firms on this list, and its listed services center on collision and death cases.
3. Lafferty, Gallagher & Scott, LLC
- Attorney/Key Figure: Jon A. Lafferty, Partner (with partners Thomas W. Gallagher and Robert “Mickey” Scott)
- Headquarters: 116 W. William Street, Maumee, OH 43537 (Toledo office at 416 N. Erie Street, Suite 400, Toledo, OH 43604)
- Phone: (419) 241-5500
- Website: lgslaw.net
- Practice Areas: Auto, truck and motorcycle accidents, uninsured and underinsured motorist law, bad faith litigation, wrongful death, medical malpractice, products liability, brain injury, birth injury
- Firm Size: Boutique firm with three named partners; the firm cites over 41 years of experience
The firm traces its roots to Williams, Jilek, Lafferty, Gallagher & Scott, and its partners are long-standing members of the Toledo plaintiffs’ bar. Partner Robert M. Scott earned his J.D. from the University of Toledo College of Law in 1984 and belongs to the Toledo Bar Association and the Toledo Area Trial Lawyers Association. The firm states that all of its attorneys are members of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum.
Lafferty, Gallagher & Scott lists uninsured and underinsured motorist law and bad faith litigation alongside crash cases, which matters when an at-fault driver carries only minimum coverage. The firm also says it is committed to challenging Ohio’s tort reform limits on damages while maximizing client compensation under current law. With three partners, its bench is smaller than at the statewide firms on this list.
4. Rubin & Zyndorf
- Attorney/Key Figure: Daryl K. Rubin, Attorney (with attorney Sol Zyndorf)
- Headquarters: 2127 Monroe Street, Toledo, OH 43604
- Phone: (419) 244-7482
- Website: lawrz.com
- Practice Areas: Car, motorcycle, truck, bicycle and pedestrian accidents, Uber and Lyft accidents, dog bites, work-related accidents, head, neck and spine injuries, wrongful death, workers’ compensation, probate
- Firm Size: Small firm with two attorneys, serving Toledo since 1982
Rubin & Zyndorf has served injured Toledo residents since 1982, and attorney Daryl K. Rubin has been licensed for more than 40 years. He is a member of the Toledo Bar Association. The firm describes its approach as hands-on: its attorneys say they will meet injured clients at the hospital or at home, which can help when a crash leaves someone unable to travel.
The firm handles car, rideshare and truck collisions and publishes settlements involving fractures, herniated discs, head injuries and death claims. It serves Lucas, Ottawa, Erie, Sandusky and Wood Counties and works on a no recovery, no fee basis. A two-attorney practice that also handles workers’ compensation and probate offers less staff depth than the larger firms on this list.
5. Williams DeClark Tuschman Co. L.P.A.
- Attorney/Key Figure: Chad M. Tuschman, Partner (with fellow partner Peter O. DeClark)
- Headquarters: 6641 Sylvania Ave, Suite 8, Sylvania, OH 43560
- Phone: (419) 387-5096
- Website: wdtlaw.org
- Practice Areas: Motor vehicle accidents, truck and motorcycle accidents, personal injury, medical malpractice, birth injury, products liability, catastrophic and construction accidents, wrongful death
- Firm Size: Boutique firm with four attorneys and over 100 years of combined experience
- Practice Area Page: Personal Injury
- Social Profiles: Facebook, X, LinkedIn, YouTube
Partner Chad M. Tuschman has practiced in Ohio since 2002. He began on the defense side, representing physicians and product manufacturers, before moving to represent injured people, which gives him a working view of how insurers and opposing counsel value a claim. Best Lawyers has named him a Toledo “Lawyer of the Year” for Personal Injury Litigation, Plaintiffs, and both he and Peter O. DeClark appear in The Best Lawyers in America. Members of the firm are past presidents of the Toledo Bar Association and the Ohio Academy of Trial Lawyers.
Best Law Firms ranks the firm Tier 1 in Toledo for Personal Injury Litigation, Plaintiffs. On the collision side, attorney Jacob J. Hamilton secured an 8-0 unanimous jury verdict in a Lucas County motor vehicle accident trial, and the firm’s published results also include multimillion-dollar catastrophic injury outcomes. With four attorneys, the bench is smaller than at the statewide firms on this list.
6. Charles E. Boyk Law Offices, LLC
- Attorney/Key Figure: Charles “Chuck” Boyk, Founder (with attorney Michael Bruno)
- Headquarters: 405 Madison Avenue, PNC Bank Building, Suite 1200, Toledo, OH 43604 (additional offices in West Toledo, Holland, Maumee, Bowling Green, Findlay, Lima, Sandusky, Fremont, Defiance and West Unity, Ohio, and Saline, Michigan)
- Phone: (877) 230-7459
- Website: charlesboyk-law.com
- Practice Areas: Car, truck, motorcycle, pedestrian, bicycle, bus, boat and train accidents, catastrophic and brain injuries, construction accidents, dog bites, premises liability, medical malpractice, workers’ compensation, product liability and mass torts, wrongful death
- Firm Size: Large regional firm with 12 offices across northwest Ohio and southeast Michigan and six attorneys listed on its website
- Practice Area Page: Practice Areas
- Social Profiles: Facebook, X, LinkedIn, YouTube, Instagram
Chuck Boyk has been licensed to practice in Ohio since 1983 and centers his work on plaintiff injury cases, including car accidents, wrongful death, medical malpractice, premises liability and construction accidents. He holds Martindale-Hubbell’s AV rating and has been selected for The Best Lawyers in America. Attorney Mike Bruno began as a Lucas County assistant prosecutor and has handled personal injury and insurance matters almost exclusively since 1989. He has tried more than 100 jury trials in northwest Ohio, including a $1.25 million recovery against a trucking company, and Best Lawyers has recognized him since 2021 for Personal Injury Litigation.
The firm’s footprint is its practical distinction: a dozen offices let clients meet an attorney close to home across the Toledo area and beyond. One practical note is that offices operate by appointment only, so walk-in consultations are not available.
7. Zoll & Kranz, LLC
- Attorney/Key Figure: Michelle L. Kranz, Founding Partner
- Headquarters: 6620 Central Ave, Suite 100, Toledo, OH 43617
- Phone: (419) 827-3194
- Website: toledolaw.com
- Practice Areas: Auto, truck, motorcycle, pedestrian and bicycle accidents, catastrophic and traumatic brain injuries, medical malpractice, nursing home abuse, wrongful death, mass torts and product liability, agricultural law
- Firm Size: Boutique firm; three attorneys are listed, including inactive founding partner David W. Zoll
- Practice Area Page: Personal Injury Lawyer
- Social Profiles: Facebook, X, LinkedIn, YouTube
Michelle L. Kranz is a founding partner of Zoll & Kranz and has represented plaintiffs for more than 30 years in car, motorcycle and truck accident cases, brain injuries and wrongful death claims. Best Lawyers has recognized her since 2017 for Personal Injury Litigation, Plaintiffs, and named her a Toledo “Lawyer of the Year” for that practice in 2019 and 2023.
The firm pairs everyday Toledo injury work, including auto accidents, brain injuries and nursing home cases, with a national mass tort docket involving dangerous drugs and defective medical devices. Best Law Firms ranks it Tier 2 in Toledo for Personal Injury Litigation, Plaintiffs. Because that national docket runs alongside the local casework, the firm’s attention is split between two kinds of practice.
8. NRS Injury Law
- Attorney/Key Figure: Daniel A. Romaine, Co-Managing Partner and Personal Injury Department Head
- Headquarters: 27730 Euclid Ave, Euclid, OH 44132 (Toledo office at 405 Madison Ave., Suite 1430, Toledo, OH 43604; additional offices in Cleveland, Columbus, Dayton and Cincinnati)
- Phone: (855) 468-4878
- Practice Areas: Auto accidents, trucking accidents, workers’ compensation, medical malpractice, nursing home abuse and neglect, mass torts, insurance coverage disputes, dog bites, slip and fall
- Firm Size: Large statewide firm, formally Nager, Romaine & Schneiberg Co., L.P.A., that describes itself as the largest injury law firm in Ohio
NRS Injury Law’s personal injury and auto accident litigation departments have been led since 2001 by Daniel A. Romaine, who graduated from Cleveland-Marshall College of Law in 1996 and belongs to the Ohio Association for Justice and the Cleveland Academy of Trial Attorneys. He was recognized among the top 50 Super Lawyers in Cleveland and the top 100 in Ohio in 2014 and 2015, and FindLaw lists the firm with 16 Super Lawyers selections.
The firm’s historic strength is workers’ compensation and personal injury, and it brings statewide resources, including a dedicated insurance coverage practice, to serious collision claims. FindLaw shows a 4.7 average across 62 client reviews for the firm. The Toledo practice is one office within a Northeast Ohio-based organization, so it is less of a local standalone practice than the boutiques on this list.
9. Schuerger Shunnarah Trial Attorneys
- Attorney/Key Figure: Robert A. Schuerger II, Co-Founder
- Headquarters: 405 Madison Avenue, Suite 1440, Toledo, OH 43604 (Toledo office of a multistate firm based at 810 Sycamore St., Suite 401, Cincinnati, OH 45202)
- Phone: (513) 480-9861
- Practice Areas: Car accidents, rideshare (Uber and Lyft) accidents, motorcycle and pedestrian accidents, truck and commercial vehicle accidents, brain, spinal cord and burn injuries, birth injury, construction and workplace injuries, wrongful death
- Firm Size: Large multistate firm announced in 2023 through a partnership between Robert Schuerger II and Alexander Shunnarah Trial Attorneys, with offices across Ohio and several other states
Robert A. Schuerger II holds a B.A. from The Ohio State University and a J.D. from Capital University Law School, began his legal career as a legislative aide in the Ohio House of Representatives, and has been selected to the Super Lawyers list. The firm states that members of its team have experience on the insurance side of injury claims and that it prepares every case with trial in mind.
Schuerger Shunnarah publishes results in transit bus accidents, commercial vehicle crashes, traumatic brain injuries and wrongful death, and it offers free case evaluations. As one of dozens of offices in a national firm, the Toledo location offers less single-attorney continuity than a boutique does.
10. Kisling, Nestico & Redick (KNR)
- Attorney/Key Figure: Anthony D. Hall, Partner, Toledo Office
- Headquarters: 6450 Monroe St, Sylvania, OH 43560 (Toledo office of a statewide firm with 12 Ohio locations)
- Phone: (419) 324-8205
- Website: knrlegal.com
- Practice Areas: Car, truck, motorcycle, pedestrian, bicycle, rideshare and boat accidents, dog bites, medical malpractice, nursing home abuse, premises liability, product liability, workers’ compensation, wrongful death
- Firm Size: Large statewide firm founded in 2005 with more than 35 lawyers; six attorneys are listed in the Toledo office
- Practice Area Page: Toledo Personal Injury Lawyers
- Social Profiles: Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, X, YouTube, TikTok
Attorneys Gary Kisling, Rob Nestico and Robert Redick opened KNR’s first office in 2005, and the firm has grown into one of Ohio’s largest personal injury practices. The Toledo office lists six attorneys: Patrick D. Hendershott, Cameron Morrissey, Brian P. Devaney, Lorri J. Britsch, Thomas J. Walsh II and partner Anthony D. Hall. The firm carries a 2026 Best Law Firms designation.
KNR’s Toledo practice publishes local case results, including a $330,000 settlement for a Toledo rear-end crash and a $250,000 settlement after a motorcycle and tractor-trailer collision, and it offers free consultations around the clock. As one office within a statewide firm, the Toledo practice draws on shared resources, which can mean less one-on-one access to a single named attorney than a boutique provides.
FAQ’s About Car Accident Lawyers in Toledo
How long do I have to file a car accident lawsuit in Ohio?
Under O.R.C. 2305.10, most personal injury lawsuits, including car accident claims, must be filed within two years of the accident, and a court will generally dismiss a case filed after the deadline. Claims against government bodies, such as a crash involving a Toledo Area Regional Transit Authority (TARTA) bus, can carry different notice and filing rules, so it pays to speak with an attorney early. Evidence such as surveillance footage and vehicle data can disappear quickly, which is why firms that rely on accident reconstruction, such as Johnson & Associates, generally want to begin gathering it right away.
Is Ohio a no-fault state, and whose insurance pays after a Toledo crash?
No. Ohio is an at-fault state, so the driver who caused the crash is responsible for the resulting damages, and that driver’s liability insurance is the usual source of payment. Ohio’s minimum liability limits are $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury and $25,000 for property damage, which can fall well short of a serious injury. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy can help fill that gap, and firms such as Lafferty, Gallagher & Scott list that coverage and bad faith litigation among their practice areas, as does Cubbon & Associates for insurance bad faith claims.
What if I was partly at fault for my accident in Toledo?
Ohio follows a modified comparative negligence rule under O.R.C. 2315.33. You can still recover compensation if you are 50 percent or less at fault, but your award is reduced by your percentage of fault, and at 51 percent or more you cannot recover. Because fault is often the central dispute in a collision case, trial results matter, such as the 8-0 unanimous Lucas County motor vehicle verdict reported by Williams DeClark Tuschman.
Is there a limit on how much I can recover for pain and suffering?
Economic losses such as medical bills and lost wages are not capped. Under O.R.C. 2315.18, non-economic damages such as pain and suffering are generally limited to the greater of $250,000 or three times your economic loss, up to $350,000 per plaintiff and $500,000 per occurrence, and the cap does not apply to certain catastrophic injuries, such as permanent and substantial physical deformity or loss of use of a limb. Because the cap turns on how severe and permanent the injury is, serious crash cases are often handled by trial-tested firms such as Zoll & Kranz and Rubin & Zyndorf.
How much does a car accident lawyer cost in Toledo?
Most Toledo car accident firms work on a contingency fee basis, which means you pay no attorney fee unless the firm recovers compensation for you, and the fee is a percentage of the recovery. Initial consultations are typically free, and firms including Rubin & Zyndorf, KNR and Schuerger Shunnarah describe free consultations or case evaluations and no fee unless you recover. Ask how case costs, such as expert fees and filing fees, are handled if there is no recovery.
Where is a Toledo car accident lawsuit filed, and how does the process work?
Most Toledo injury lawsuits are filed in the Lucas County Court of Common Pleas at 700 Adams Street in downtown Toledo, which handles civil claims where the amount in dispute exceeds $15,000. Filing starts with a complaint and a filing fee, after which the defendant is served, a judge is assigned and the case moves into discovery. Most cases settle before trial, but an attorney with real courtroom experience adds leverage. For example, Boyk Law Offices attorney Mike Bruno has tried more than 100 jury trials in northwest Ohio.
Disclaimer: For informational use only. This content is not legal advice or an endorsement. Personal injury matters in Ohio are governed by specific state statutes and court rules. Attorney qualifications change over time; always independently verify credentials directly with the firm and the Supreme Court of Ohio’s Office of Attorney Services, and consult qualified counsel before retaining representation.
