This guide compares 10 law firms that defend DUI charges for drivers arrested in Carmel and the rest of Hamilton County, Indiana, where the offense is formally called OWI (operating while intoxicated). Firms were evaluated on their background and credentials, including time spent as prosecutors; how much of their practice is OWI and criminal defense versus general practice; their familiarity with the Hamilton County courts in Noblesville; and how close their offices are to Carmel. Firms that practice criminal defense exclusively or maintain dedicated OWI pages are noted as such.
When comparing options, three practical questions matter most. Does the attorney appear regularly in Hamilton County, where misdemeanor and Level 6 felony OWI cases are typically filed in the county’s Superior Courts? Has the attorney worked on the prosecution side, for example on a fatal alcohol crash team or in a county prosecutor’s office, and so knows how an OWI case is built? And does the firm also handle the parallel license issues, such as specialized driving privileges, that run alongside the criminal case?
Quick View: Top 3 DUI Defense Law Firms in Carmel, IN
#1. Blankenship Law, LLC
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5.0 (326 reviews)
#2. The Criminal Defense Team
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.6 (41 reviews)
#3. Keffer Hirschauer LLP
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.5 (275 review)
- Quick View: Top 3 DUI Defense Law Firms in Carmel, IN
- 1. Blankenship Law, LLC
- 2. The Criminal Defense Team (Baldwin, Perry & Wiley, PC)
- 3. Keffer Hirschauer LLP
- 4. Stark DUI Lawyers
- 5. Davis Law Office, LLC
- 6. Avnet Law
- 7. Law Offices of Jason Jackson & Associates
- 8. Joel Hand Law
- 9. Sauce & Tardy, Attorneys at Law
- 10. Terry Legal Group, LLC
- Carmel, IN DUI Law Resources
- Understanding Carmel, IN DUI Law Court Procedures
1. Blankenship Law, LLC

- Attorney/Key Figure: Eric Blankenship, Founder and Managing Attorney (with attorneys Kevin Kelly and Alec Baker)
- Headquarters: 11405 N. Pennsylvania St., Suite 115, Carmel, IN 46032 (additional office in Valparaiso, IN)
- Phone: 317-669-9010
- Website: ericblankenshiplaw.com
- Practice Areas: DUI/OWI, prescription drug OWI, OWI with a controlled substance, under-21 OWI, marijuana defense, drug crimes, expungements, domestic violence, violent crimes, theft
- Firm Size: Boutique criminal defense firm with three attorneys, former prosecutors, 5.0 rating on Google across 326 reviews
- Practice Area Page: Carmel DUI/OWI Lawyer
- Social Profiles: Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram
About the Firm: Eric Blankenship began his career as a deputy prosecutor in Hamilton County after passing the bar in 2002. He was then recruited to the Marion County Prosecutor’s Office, where he rose to Major Felony Supervisor over four felony courts, and later served as Chief Deputy Prosecuting Attorney for Blackford County. Over 17 years as a prosecutor he tried well over 100 court and jury trials, including DUI cases, before moving to the defense side.
Blankenship Law practices criminal defense exclusively, and its Carmel office sits inside the city, so a Carmel arrest is handled by a local team that is available around the clock. The firm publishes dedicated pages for the OWI scenarios people search for most: prescription drug OWI, OWI involving a controlled substance, and under-21 OWI. Its published results include a first-time OWI arrest with a .10 breath test that ended without an OWI conviction, resolved instead as a reckless driving plea with six months of probation.
2. The Criminal Defense Team (Baldwin, Perry & Wiley, PC)

- Attorney/Key Figure: Andrew Baldwin, Kathie Perry and Max Wiley, named partners
- Headquarters: 23 S 8th St., Suite 50, Noblesville, IN 46060 (Hamilton County office; flagship office at 150 N. Main St., Franklin, IN, plus an Indianapolis office)
- Phone: (317) 687-8326
- Website: criminaldefenseteam.com
- Practice Areas: DUI/OWI, underage DUI, felony DUI, drug crimes, violent crimes, sex crimes, federal crimes, gun crimes, domestic battery, expungement
- Firm Size: Mid-size criminal defense firm with seven attorneys across three offices, founded in 2007
- Practice Area Page: Carmel DUI Lawyer
- Social Profiles: Facebook, X, Instagram, LinkedIn, YouTube
About the Firm: The Criminal Defense Team practices criminal defense exclusively. Andrew Baldwin, Kathie Perry and Kelly Pyle are listed as certified in Criminal Trial Law by the National Board of Trial Advocacy, a credential held by a small group of Indiana lawyers. Max Wiley, a partner who has practiced as both a defense attorney and a prosecutor handling high profile cases, has been instrumental in building the firm’s Hamilton County practice.
The firm’s team approach is the main differentiator: it pairs lawyers on trials and shares strategy across its three offices, and it publishes separate pages for felony DUI, underage DUI and other OWI scenarios. For a Carmel arrest, its Noblesville office is the one that handles Hamilton County cases, where the firm says several of its lawyers have tried cases together before juries.
3. Keffer Hirschauer LLP

- Attorney/Key Figure: Bradley Keffer and Tom Hirschauer III, founders
- Headquarters: 8440 Allison Pointe Boulevard, Suite 100, Indianapolis, IN 46250
- Phone: (317) 857-0160
- Website: indyjustice.com
- Practice Areas: Criminal defense including drunk driving, expungement, family law, Title IX defense, professional licensure, gun rights
- Firm Size: Boutique litigation firm
- Practice Area Page: Drunk Driving
About the Firm: Bradley Keffer and Tom Hirschauer III are former prosecutors, and the firm says its DUI team is the only one in Indiana led by two former Fatal Alcohol Crash Team (FACT) prosecutors. The firm also states that both founders are members of the National College of DUI Defense. Keffer describes his practice as entirely litigation-focused, with experience in complex and high-profile state and federal matters.
The firm publishes detailed Carmel, Fishers and Noblesville DUI pages covering how Indiana penalties escalate with prior offenses and which defenses it uses, from the legality of the traffic stop to how breath and blood evidence was handled. Its office is in the Castleton area of Indianapolis, northeast of Carmel, and the firm also handles family law and Title IX matters, so DUI is one practice among several.
4. Stark DUI Lawyers

- Attorney/Key Figure: Gregg J. Stark, Founder
- Headquarters: 450 E. 96th St., Suite 500, Indianapolis, IN 46240
- Phone: (317) 846-7777
- Website: indianaduiattorney.org
- Practice Areas: DUI/OWI, criminal defense
- Firm Size: Solo practice, licensed in Indiana since 1991
About the Firm: Gregg Stark has practiced in Indiana since 1991 and markets himself as a former DUI prosecutor now defending DUI cases. His firm focuses on DUI and criminal defense and says it has been consulted on cases in all 92 Indiana counties, representing clients that include other lawyers, police officers and professional athletes. He also publishes an Indiana DUI law blog and a statewide criminal defense blog.
His office sits on 96th Street at the Carmel line, which makes it one of the closest DUI-focused offices to Carmel residents. As a solo practice, every case is handled by Stark personally rather than by a larger team, which suits clients who want a single, senior point of contact.
5. Davis Law Office, LLC

- Attorney/Key Figure: Steven S. Davis, attorney
- Headquarters: 13295 North Illinois Street, Suite 328, Carmel, IN 46032
- Phone: 317-660-8019
- Website: davis-law.net
- Practice Areas: OWI/DUI, traffic tickets, drug charges, weapons charges, theft, domestic violence, expungement, family law
- Firm Size: Small local firm, serving clients since 2009
About the Firm: Davis Law Office is based in Carmel and has defended people accused of crimes in Central Indiana since 2009, with OWI/DUI listed first among the charges it handles. Steven Davis is listed in directories as a Carmel DUI attorney, and the firm describes keeping clients informed throughout a case and checking in with some clients after their cases conclude.
Because the office is in Carmel, it is one of the most convenient options for residents who want to meet in person. The firm combines criminal defense with family law, so OWI is one of several areas it covers rather than its only focus.
6. Avnet Law

- Attorney/Key Figure: Ary Avnet, Founder
- Headquarters: 34 S 9th St, Noblesville, IN 46060
- Phone: (877) 772-8638
- Website: avnetlaw.com
- Practice Areas: Criminal defense including DUI/OWI, personal injury, family law, expungement
- Firm Size: Boutique firm, 5.0 rating on Google across 168 reviews
- Practice Area Page: Carmel, Indiana DUI Lawyer
About the Firm: Ary Avnet started in insurance defense litigation in Hamilton County, then defended trucking companies in large negligence and wrongful death suits at a national transportation law firm before returning to Hamilton County to found Avnet Law. The firm lists a 2019 Avvo Clients’ Choice Award, and its Carmel DUI page lays out how OWI cases are assigned within the county, explaining that misdemeanor and Level 6 felony cases are typically filed in Hamilton Superior Courts 4, 5, 6 and 7.
Avnet Law’s page also walks through the issues that most affect a first OWI: eligibility for pretrial diversion, specialized driving privileges, and challenges to how the stop and chemical test were handled. The firm’s office is in Noblesville, close to the courthouse where Carmel OWI cases are heard, and its practice spans criminal, family and injury work rather than OWI alone.
7. Law Offices of Jason Jackson & Associates

- Attorney/Key Figure: Jason Jackson, Founding Attorney
- Headquarters: 499 S 9th St, Noblesville, IN 46060 (additional office at 710 Brown St., Lafayette, IN)
- Phone: (317) 799-1675
- Website: jasonjacksonlaw.com
- Practice Areas: Criminal defense, DUI/OWI, traffic violations, domestic violence, white collar crime, drug and gun charges
- Firm Size: Boutique criminal defense firm
About the Firm: Jason Jackson was admitted to the Indiana bar in 2000, graduated from the Indiana University Maurer School of Law, and has led his own firm since 2002. His FindLaw profile lists an AV Preeminent rating and Super Lawyers recognition, and describes about 25 years of criminal defense experience.
The firm is based in Noblesville, which puts it near the Hamilton County courts, with a second office in Lafayette. It handles DUI and OWI alongside the full range of criminal charges, so it fits clients who want a general criminal defense firm with local courthouse presence rather than a dedicated DUI boutique.
8. Joel Hand Law

- Attorney/Key Figure: Joel D. Hand, Owner and Attorney
- Headquarters: 1512 N Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
- Phone: (317) 550-0778
- Website: joelhandlaw.com
- Practice Areas: DUI/OWI, criminal defense, domestic violence, traffic tickets, juvenile and education law
- Firm Size: Solo practice, admitted to the Indiana bar in 1995
About the Firm: Joel Hand has one of the more specialized DUI backgrounds on this list. In 2004 he was appointed Indiana’s first Traffic Safety Resource Prosecutor, a role in which he trained prosecutors and police officers on investigating and prosecuting impaired driving. He served as a deputy prosecutor in Hamilton County and in Marion County, acted as a Fatal Alcohol Crash Team prosecutor, and later was Chief Deputy Prosecutor in Carroll County. His profile also lists the 2007 M.A.D.D. National Prosecutor of the Year Award.
That training gives him an insider’s view of how police are taught to build an OWI case. His office is downtown Indianapolis, south of Carmel, and as a solo practice he personally handles each case, which means less bench depth than a larger firm but direct access to a former statewide DUI trainer.
9. Sauce & Tardy, Attorneys at Law

- Attorney/Key Figure: Harry Sauce, attorney (with partner Rick Tardy)
- Headquarters: 829 Conner St, Noblesville, IN 46060
- Phone: (317) 773-3737
- Website: harrysauce.com
- Practice Areas: DUI/DWI/OWI, criminal defense (felonies, misdemeanors, juvenile), probation, divorce and family law, personal injury, Social Security disability
- Firm Size: Small general practice
About the Firm: Harry Sauce has practiced in Hamilton County for over 30 years. He has served as a Master Commissioner of the Hamilton County Circuit Court, as an elected judge of the Hamilton County Court for fifteen years, and as a Deputy Attorney General, which gives him direct experience on the bench in the county where Carmel OWI cases are heard.
The firm advertises reasonable rates and flexible payments and lists DUI/OWI defense as one of Harry Sauce’s main practice areas. It is a general practice, so OWI sits alongside divorce, personal injury and disability work, and clients looking for a firm that handles only DUI would find a narrower focus elsewhere on this list.
10. Terry Legal Group, LLC

- Attorney/Key Figure: Terry Legal Group attorneys (DUI team includes a former Hamilton County deputy prosecutor)
- Headquarters: 301 East Carmel Drive, Suite C300, Carmel, IN 46032
- Phone: 888-881-8207
- Website: tandglaw.com
- Practice Areas: OWI/drunk driving defense, criminal law, and a range of civil practice areas
- Firm Size: Full-service firm
About the Firm: Terry Legal Group is a full-service firm with an office on East Carmel Drive, in the heart of Carmel. Its DUI team includes a former Hamilton County deputy prosecutor and a long-time criminal defense attorney, a pairing the firm says gives it insight into the prosecutor’s perspective. It also offers 30-minute telephone consultations at any hour.
As a full-service firm, OWI is one of many practice areas, so the DUI team is part of a broader firm rather than a dedicated defense practice. Its location makes it among the most convenient for Carmel residents who want an in-person meeting close to home.
Carmel, IN DUI Law Resources
- Hamilton County Courts – Provides court information and resources relevant to DUI cases handled in Hamilton County.
- Carmel Police Department – Offers information about local law enforcement services, traffic enforcement, and public safety.
- Indiana Judicial Branch – Provides court resources, legal forms, and information about Indiana’s judicial system.
- Indiana General Assembly – Access Indiana statutes covering operating while intoxicated (OWI), penalties, and related offenses.
- Indiana Bureau of Motor Vehicles – Provides information about driver’s license suspensions, reinstatement requirements, and driving privileges.
- Indiana Legal Help – Offers legal information and resources to help people understand their rights and navigate legal issues.
Understanding Carmel, IN DUI Law Court Procedures
- Arrest and Booking: Following a suspected DUI, known as operating while intoxicated (OWI) in Indiana, the individual may be arrested, booked, and informed of the charges.
- Initial Hearing: The court explains the charges, advises the defendant of their rights, and addresses release conditions. License suspension may also become an issue.
- Pretrial Proceedings: The defense and prosecution review evidence, including police reports, chemical test results, and field sobriety test observations.
- License Suspension: A failed or refused chemical test may trigger administrative consequences for driving privileges under Indiana law.
- Plea Negotiations: The defense may negotiate with the prosecution to explore possible resolutions.
- Trial: If the case proceeds to trial, the prosecution presents evidence, and the defense challenges the allegations.
- Sentencing: A conviction may result in fines, license suspension, probation, or other penalties, depending on the circumstances and applicable law.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between DUI and OWI in Indiana?
Indiana’s statutes use the term OWI, operating while intoxicated, while DUI is the everyday term most people search for, and some firms also say OVWI for operating a vehicle while intoxicated. They describe the same family of charges: driving while impaired by alcohol, drugs or a combination. Impairment can be shown by a blood alcohol concentration at or above the legal limit or by evidence that alcohol or drugs affected your driving, and the limit is lower for drivers under 21. Several firms in this guide, including Blankenship Law, publish separate pages for under-21, prescription drug and controlled substance OWI because each is charged and defended differently.
What penalties can a first OWI carry in Indiana?
A first OWI is usually charged as a misdemeanor. A Class C misdemeanor carries up to 60 days in jail and a fine up to $500, and a Class A misdemeanor carries up to one year and a fine up to $5,000. Courts commonly add probation of up to two years, a substance abuse evaluation, a victim impact panel, random drug and alcohol screens and court costs, and a license suspension that can run up to two years. Prior convictions, a very high test result, or an accident causing injury can raise the charge to a felony, with Level 6 felonies carrying six months to two and a half years and higher levels carrying more.
Which court hears a Carmel OWI case?
Carmel is in Hamilton County, and OWI cases are handled by the county’s courts in Noblesville. Hamilton County has seven Superior Courts and one Circuit Court, and misdemeanor and Level 6 felony OWI cases are typically filed in Hamilton Superior Courts 4, 5, 6 and 7, according to Avnet Law, while more serious felony charges can be filed in the other courts. That is why local familiarity matters: judges, prosecutors and diversion practices vary from county to county.
Can I keep driving after an OWI arrest?
Not automatically. A license suspension can follow a conviction, and a refusal to take a chemical test can lead to its own suspension, separate from the criminal case. Indiana allows specialized driving privileges in some situations, which can let a person drive to work, school, church, medical appointments and court hearings. Whether you qualify depends on the details of your case, which is one reason to speak with a lawyer before assuming your license is lost.
Can I be charged with OWI for prescription medication or marijuana?
Yes. An OWI charge can be based on impairment from a prescription drug or a controlled substance, not only alcohol, and having a valid prescription does not automatically end the case if the state believes the medication impaired your driving. Blankenship Law publishes separate guidance on prescription drug OWI and OWI with a controlled substance, which are typically proven through blood testing and officer observations rather than a breath test.
How do I choose between a solo lawyer, a boutique firm and a larger team?
It depends on what you value. A solo practitioner such as Stark DUI Lawyers or Joel Hand Law puts one attorney on your file from start to finish. A boutique firm such as Keffer Hirschauer LLP offers a small team with a former prosecutor’s perspective. A larger criminal defense firm such as The Criminal Defense Team can pair lawyers on a trial and share strategy across offices. Also ask whether the lawyer has prosecuted OWI cases, how often they appear in the Hamilton County courts, and whether they handle license issues alongside the criminal charge.
Disclaimer: This guide covers OWI and DUI charges in Carmel and Hamilton County, Indiana. The penalty ranges, charge levels, license suspensions, court assignments and diversion options described here are general summaries and not a complete statement of Indiana law for any single case. Outcomes in OWI cases turn on facts such as the reason for the traffic stop, how breath or blood testing was performed, your prior record and the exact charges filed. This guide is not a substitute for advice from a licensed Indiana attorney about your own situation.



